The title of Chapter 12 is “Neurotic Disorders in Human Relationships.”
Neurotic individuals are dominated by an internal “system of pride” consisting of an idealized self-image, the tyranny of “shoulds,” and externalization, resulting in egocentrism. This is not mere selfishness, but a state in which all energy is consumed by internal conflict, which leads to the following three main impairments in interpersonal relationships:
1. Egocentrism and Alienation from Others
Emotional Isolation: Neurotic individuals primarily live in their own inner world, detached from the real emotional world. Therefore, they cannot perceive others as independent individuals.
Distorted Perception of Others: They distort others according to their own internal desires (e.g., those who want to be worshipped see others as spectators, and those striving for perfection see others as defective).
Externalization: Projecting internal conflicts, such as self-hatred, onto the external world (e.g., those who are inwardly tyrannical perceive others as tyrants, and those who despise themselves feel everyone despises them).
2. Fundamental Uncertainty Regarding Others
Neurotic individuals lack stable, realistic feelings towards others and live in a fundamental “uncertainty.”
– Relationship Uncertainty: Even while calling someone a “friend,” they doubt the relationship based on minor misunderstandings.
– Impaired Trust: They fluctuate between excessive trust and complete distrust, unable to make stable, reality-based judgments.
3. Coexistence of Fear and Hostility
This uncertainty is accompanied by intense fear.
– Reinforcement of Basic Anxiety: Neurotic individuals significantly reinforce the “basic anxiety” (a feeling of helplessness in a hostile world) formed in childhood, due to their tendency to view their own vulnerability and others as threats. – Defensive attitudes: Because they feel vulnerable and in danger, they adopt defensive attitudes such as aggression, submission, or distance.
A key insight in this chapter is the following fundamental contradiction:
– On the one hand, neurotics feel alienated from others and harbor uncertainty, fear, and hostility.
– On the other hand, they have an extreme need for others. The reasons are as follows:
– To have their illusory self-worth (praise, approval, love) confirmed.
– To have others defend them from intense self-hatred and self-blame.
– To use others as a “partner” to externalize their internal conflicts.
In short, neurotics are trapped between the extremes of “estrangement” and “dependence,” and are unable to build honest and reciprocal partnerships.
While neurosis brings significant difficulties to interpersonal relationships, Horney also points out the possibility that a healthy social environment can play a crucial role in treatment.
– Early Childhood: A warm and understanding environment can halt and redirect neurotic development.
– Adulthood: When the pride system is not deeply ingrained, a stable and healthy relationship (such as marriage or a therapeutic relationship) can help in the following ways:
– The patient feels accepted and belongs to the community.
– The intensity of externalization is reduced.
– The patient develops the courage to confront their problems and fosters inner growth.
Chapter 12 systematically discusses how the inner conflicts of neurotics distort their perspective on others, like a “distorted mirror,” creating a vicious cycle in interpersonal relationships.
↓Please click the banners below.
コメント